Item Information
Title:Application to permit the demolition of the Ugandan High Commission, 231 Cobourg Street, a property located in the Wilbrod Laurier Heritage Conservation District and application for new construction on the same site

Item #: Status:
Type:1 1 #:RIDEAU-VANIER (12)
Version:1st Sponsor:
Meeting Date:2018-Apr-12 2018-Apr-12 2 Ward:RIDEAU-VANIER (12)
Meeting Type:BHSC Video: View Video
Attachments:Document 5 – Heritage Survey Form    Document 6 – Structural Assessment Report 2017    Document 7 – Geotechnical Assessment 2013    Document 8 – Building Condition Assessment 2013    Document 9 – ASI Geotechnical Investigation 2017    Document 10 – JCAL Building Condition Report 2018    Document 15 – Cultural Heritage Impact Statement    
Text
History
 VersionItem #TypeStatusMeeting DateMeeting Type
 1st12018-Apr-12BHSC
 2nd12018-Apr-24PLC
Vote Records
Passed    Motion To: WHEREAS the Cultural Heritage Impact Statement (CHIS), referenced in the report as Document 15, which was distributed with the agenda for the BHSC meeting of April 12, 2018 was not the most current version of the CHIS; BE IT RESOLVED THAT the CHIS be replaced with the most current version dated November 22, 2017, prepared by Robertson Martin Architects.
(Councillor / Conseiller) S. Moffatt  Yes
(Public Member) B. Padolsky  Yes
(Public Member) L. A. (Sandy) Smallwood  Yes
(Councillor / Conseillère) M. Wilkinson  Yes
(Public Member) C. Quinn  Yes
(Councillor / Conseillère) C. McKenney  Yes
(Councillor / Conseiller) T. Nussbaum  Yes
Failed    Motion To: That the Built Heritage Sub-Committee recommend that Planning Committee recommend that Council: 1. Approve the application to demolish the Ugandan High Commission, 231 Cobourg Street, submitted by Ten 2 Four Architecture Inc. received on December 8, 2017; 2. Approve the construction of a new building at 231 Cobourg Street according to plans by Ten 2 Four Architecture Inc. received on March 19, 2018; 3. Delegate authority for minor design changes to the General Manager, Planning, Infrastructure and Economic Development Department; 4. Issue the heritage permit with an expiry date of either: (a) two years from the date of issuance; or (b) two years from the date that decisions on applications under the Planning Act are final and binding; whichever is later. (Note: The statutory 90-day timeline for consideration of this application under the Ontario Heritage Act has been extended to 15 May 2018.) (Note: Approval to alter this property under the Ontario Heritage Act must not be construed to meet the requirements for the issuance of a building permit.)
(Councillor / Conseiller) S. Moffatt  No
(Public Member) B. Padolsky  No
(Public Member) L. A. (Sandy) Smallwood  No
(Councillor / Conseillère) M. Wilkinson  Yes
(Public Member) C. Quinn  No
(Councillor / Conseillère) C. McKenney  No
(Councillor / Conseiller) T. Nussbaum  Yes
Passed    Motion To: WHEREAS Report ACS2018-PIE-RHU-0009 recommends approval of the application; AND WHEREAS the Built Heritage Sub-Committee wish to recommend refusal of the application for demolition, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that Recommendations 1 and 2 of the staff report be amended as follows: 1. Delete the word “approve” and replace it with “refuse”; AND THAT Recommendations 3 and 4 be deleted
(Councillor / Conseiller) S. Moffatt  Yes
(Public Member) B. Padolsky  Yes
(Public Member) L. A. (Sandy) Smallwood  Yes
(Councillor / Conseillère) M. Wilkinson  No
(Public Member) C. Quinn  Yes
(Councillor / Conseillère) C. McKenney  Yes
(Councillor / Conseiller) T. Nussbaum  No